Searching for the Best Cannoli in NYC: From Little Italy to the Bronx, Here Are the Authentic Sicilian Cannoli Worth Trying!

As an Italian with a passion for authentic desserts, during my stay in New York, I was determined to find the best cannoli in NYC that truly captured the essence of genuine Italian flavors.

With the city’s incredible selection of Italian bakeries, I relied on existing rankings and recommendations to compile a list of the top-rated spots. I then set out to try these renowned bakeries myself. The result? A delicious journey through New York City’s finest cannoli offerings.

Read on to discover where to find the most authentic and mouthwatering Italian Cannoli in the Big Apple!

Gino’s Pastry Shop & Cafe: Famous Cannoli Places in NYC

Located at 580 E 187th St, Bronx, Gino’s Pastry Shop & Cafe has been a beloved spot for over 60 years. Known for their delicious italian cannoli, this iconic bakery has earned a reputation throughout the tri-state area. The shop’s owner, Jerome, famously known as “The Cannoli King,” brought even more fame to Gino’s after its feature in Chazz Palminteri’s “The Bronx Tale.”

The cannoli here are filled to order, ensuring freshness and a delightful crunch. Besides cannoli, their rum baba is a must-try! The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it a perfect spot to enjoy some of the best Italian pastries in NYC. The friendly service and old-world charm add to the unique experience.

La Bella Ferrara: Best Cannoli in Little Italy NYC

If you’re craving the best cannoli in NYC, head to La Bella Ferrara in Little Italy. Located at 108 Mulberry St, this iconic spot has been delighting locals and tourists alike since 1970. Founded by Sicilian-born Frank and Nick Angileri, this bakery offers an authentic taste of Sicily right in the heart of Manhattan.

The cannoli here are a must-try, filled with sweet ricotta and sometimes adorned with chocolate chips or cherries. Stepping into La Bella Ferrara feels like being transported to a Sicilian pasticceria, making it a nostalgic and delicious experience. Don’t miss this gem for some of the best Italian pastries in NYC.

Veniero’s Pasticceria & Caffe: Legendary Cannoli in NYC

Step into Veniero’s Pasticceria & Caffe, a New York institution that has delighted dessert lovers for over 128 years. Founded by Antonio Veniero, this family-owned bakery preserves its award-winning recipes praised in Rome and the New York World Fair.

Located at 342 E 11th St, Veniero’s is famous for its exquisite Italian cannoli, available in flavors like plain, chocolate-covered, and pistachio-studded. For the best cannoli in NYC, this is a must-visit spot. Can’t visit in person? Veniero’s offers nationwide delivery on fill-your-own cannoli kits.

Cerasella: Authentic Italian Cannoli Delight in NYC

If you’re on the hunt for the best cannoli in NYC, look no further than Cerasella. Located at 36-27 31st St, Queens, this charming caffetteria, opened in 2020 by a passionate husband-and-wife team, has quickly earned a stellar reputation in the neighborhood.

The authentic Italian pastries here are a delight, especially the Sicilian cannoli. The cozy atmosphere, reminiscent of a traditional Italian coffee shop, invites you to chat with the owners while savoring exceptional desserts and coffee. For an authentic Italian experience and some of the top cannoli in NYC, Cerasella is a must-visit spot.

Ferrara Bakery & Cafe: Best Cannoli in Little Italy NYC

Ferrara Bakery & Cafe is a must-visit spot for the best cannoli in NYC. Located at 195 Grand St, this iconic bakery has been delighting dessert lovers since 1892. Known as the oldest pasticceria and espresso bar in America, Ferrara has a rich history and has served many famous patrons, including Frank Sinatra.

Their cannoli, available in various flavors including chocolate-covered and pistachio-studded, are simply irresistible. If you’re looking for the best Italian pastries in NYC, Ferrara Bakery & Cafe should be at the top of your list.

Circo’s Pastry Shop: NYC’s Best Cannoli Spots

For a true taste of Sicily in the heart of Brooklyn, head to Circo’s Pastry Shop in Bushwick. Located at 312 Knickerbocker Ave, Brooklyn, this charming bakery has been delighting customers since 1945.

The cannoli here are legendary, filled with sweet ricotta and often topped with cherries or chocolate chips. The welcoming atmosphere and the incredible pastries make it a favorite spot for locals and tourists alike. Don’t miss the chance to experience one of NYC’s best cannoli spots at Circo’s Pastry Shop.

Gian Piero Bakery: Top Cannoli in NYC

If you’re on the hunt for the best cannoli in NYC, Gian Piero Bakery in Queens should be on your list. Located at 4417 30th Ave, Queens, this charming bakery was founded by Michael Della Polla in 1995, inspired by his desire to recreate the authentic Italian baking of his childhood.

Gian Piero Bakery is renowned for its exquisite cannoli, with crispy shells and creamy ricotta filling, often topped with chocolate chips. Each bite transports you to the streets of Sicily, and the welcoming atmosphere makes it a favorite spot for both locals and visitors. Don’t forget to pair your cannoli with a delicious espresso for the full experience.

Villabate Alba: Best Cannoli in NYC

When searching for the best cannoli in NYC, Villabate Alba in Brooklyn should be at the top of your list. Located at 7001 18th Ave Brooklyn, this legendary bakery brings founded by Angelo Alaimo and his son Emanuele, is renowned for using ricotta imported from Palermo, Sicily.

The fresco-painted ceilings and the warm atmosphere make you feel like you’re back in Italy. Their cannoli, filled with sweet ricotta and topped with cherries, are simply divine. With a history that traces back to a small commune outside Palermo, Villabate Alba offers an authentic taste of Italian dessert right here in Brooklyn.